Massachusetts Regulator Warns Prediction Markets Bypass Betting Safeguards for Young People

Jordan Maynard told Congress that products resembling sportsbook wagers can evade the state’s age, advertising and college-athlete restrictions.
Massachusetts Regulator Warns Prediction Markets Bypass Betting Safeguards for Young People
Key points
  • Jordan Maynard told a House panel that prediction markets can sidestep Massachusetts sports-betting protections.
  • The commission says consumers regularly seek its help with prediction-market disputes despite its lack of jurisdiction over the platforms.
  • Massachusetts was one of two jurisdictions with all six protections tracked in a new sports-betting policy database.
  • The tracker does not assess prediction markets, while a NORC study found widespread sports-betting experience among its Massachusetts young-adult participants.

Massachusetts Gaming Commission Chair Jordan Maynard told a House hearing on Nov. 11 that prediction-market platforms are bypassing safeguards that the state applies to licensed sports betting, including its minimum gambling age, advertising rules and restrictions on college-athlete wagers.

In written testimony to the House Subcommittee on Higher Education and Workforce Development, Maynard said products offered as sports prediction contracts can look much the same to consumers as sportsbook bets, while falling under different regulatory systems. He said companies were offering sports wagers while characterising them differently to avoid state laws, taxes and regulatory requirements.

Massachusetts requires sports bettors to be at least 21, but Maynard testified that most prediction-market platforms permit accounts and sports gambling from age 18. He said the platforms also offer individual college-player proposition contracts, which licensed sportsbooks in Massachusetts are prohibited from taking.

The commission receives regular requests from residents who believe it regulates sports prediction markets and seek help with disputes, consumer protection or responsible gambling, according to Maynard. The regulator directs those consumers to the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Maynard told lawmakers that the split between state sports-betting regulation and federal prediction-market oversight had created consumer confusion.

Massachusetts launched legal sports wagering in early 2023 and requires licensed operators to use age-verification technology. Those checks have blocked at least 11,000 attempts by people under 21 to open accounts. The state also bars sports-betting advertising on college campuses and in or around venues hosting college games, bans bets on the individual performance of college athletes, and generally prohibits wagering on in-state college teams outside tournaments.

Maynard said the industry’s rapid expansion had, in some cases, outpaced the state’s ability to implement or revise consumer-protection rules. The commission has brought 39 monetary enforcement actions against operators, producing more than $1 million in penalties for the Commonwealth and nearly $10 million returned to patrons for operator errors.

The warning came as the Sports Betting Consumer Protection Tracker catalogued substantial differences among 35 state-licensed sports-betting jurisdictions. Built by San Diego State University associate professor Brandon Mastromartino, it tracks six written policy areas: youth-focused advertising, “risk-free” language, bonus disclosures, helpline messages, marketing to self-excluded bettors and credit-card deposits.

Massachusetts and Colorado were the only jurisdictions recorded as having all six protections. In Massachusetts, advertisements must include the state problem-gambling helpline, material promotion conditions must be clear and conspicuous, marketing to self-excluded people is barred, and operators cannot accept credit cards. The state also prohibits describing a wager as free, cost-free or free of risk when a bettor’s money is at stake.

Across the tracker, only seven jurisdictions restrict “risk-free” betting language, 20 require a problem-gambling helpline in every advertisement, 18 restrict ads aimed at people under 21 or on college campuses, and 12 prohibit credit-card deposits. The tracker measures written rules rather than operator conduct, and explicitly does not cover prediction markets, so its results do not assess the safeguards on the platforms Maynard criticised.

Research has underscored why young adults are central to the debate. A NORC study of Massachusetts residents ages 18 to 25 found that 71% of participants had bet on sports, with many treating it as casual, low-risk entertainment akin to buying coffee or lunch. Participants linked the normalisation of sports betting to peers, mobile access and pervasive advertising; some also reported using prediction markets.

In September 2025, the Massachusetts attorney general sued Kalshi in state court, seeking to stop the company from operating in violation of the state’s sports-wagering law. A court granted the requested injunction, and Kalshi appealed to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court.